After a few months of checking the local papers, scouring the internet, and keeping my eye on the "For Sale" section here, we saw this '68 Dodge come and go on eBay that would make a good candidate. It never reached the reserve so I dropped the owner a PM after the auction, we arranged to meet (he's just over an hour from us), and by the end of this past weekend a deal was made for $3,750. Just around where we were hoping to spend.
There's some rust ready to pop through the paint in a few places near the rear wheel wells but other then that she's in real nice shape and runs strong. The rear doors seem to be sealed shut but we're hoping we can have them functioning again without too much of a hassle. I'm not really digging the vertical stripes, bumpers, or hubcaps so those will be the first things to go.
Here's some pics from the eBay auction. I'm looking forward to posting a few more once she's home!